A Brothers Vow

Nora Hill

After completing a PhD in Animal Science, I fed my Peter Pan syndrome by attending PA school shortly after meeting my now wife. While credentialing


It became easy for Brother Bill McCormick to feel at home at St. Joseph’s Monastery. The lush apple orchards, bustling bakery, and mostly lovable rest of the cloister. Yet, Bill wants something more. Luckily, or unluckily, he receives a letter which sets off an unfortunate series of events which fling open the door to his past and upset his monastic life. But the fates will ultimately offer Brother Bill the chance to reconcile his past and find a life and love outside the monastery walls.

Title: The Difficulty in Leaving Religious Orders: An In-Depth Analysis

Introduction: Leaving religious orders can often be a formidable challenge for individuals who have dedicated their lives to a religious vocation. This essay aims to explore the intricate complexities and multifaceted factors influencing the difficulty in leaving religious orders. By delving into psychological, emotional, societal, and spiritual aspects, we will gain a comprehensive understanding of the experiences faced by those contemplating exit from these religious communities.

The Psychological Struggles: Leaving a religious order can initiate a significant psychological struggle within individuals. Most often, members have spent years immersed in a structured environment that shapes their identity, worldview, and daily routines. Consequently, detaching oneself from the familiar and embarking on an uncertain journey poses numerous psychological hurdles, including identity crisis, fear of the unknown, and a sense of loss.

Emotional Challenges: The emotional challenges associated with leaving religious orders are profound. Many individuals experience emotional trauma due to the intense bonds formed with fellow members and the loss of a supportive community network. Feelings of guilt, disconnection, and loneliness frequently arise, leading to a deep internal conflict between personal desires for freedom and the commitment to religious beliefs.

Societal Reintegration: Reintegrating into mainstream society after leaving a religious order can be a daunting task for several reasons. Extended periods of seclusion from the outside world can diminish individuals’ knowledge and proficiency in various societal norms and skills. Additionally, stigmatization, judgment, and discrimination from the wider community may arise due to unfamiliarity with religious orders, leading to social alienation.

Social Repercussions: In certain societies, the decision to leave a religious order can bear severe social repercussions. Family and friends may disapprove or reject those who choose to abandon their religious lifestyle, leading to strained relationships. Such hostility can exacerbate the difficulty in transitioning away from religious orders as individuals are torn between adhering to their own beliefs and preserving familial connections.

Spiritual Dilemmas: Departing from a religious order often generates profound spiritual dilemmas. Many individuals experience a crisis of faith, questioning their belief systems, values, and spirituality. The loss of the structured spiritual practices they have engaged in for years may leave religious converts feeling adrift, searching for new frameworks to make sense of their place in the world.

Legal and Practical Obstacles: Leaving a religious order may entail confronting numerous legal and practical obstacles. In some cases, individuals need to relinquish financial dependency on the order or navigate legal issues related to property or assets. Additionally, practical concerns such as securing housing, finding employment, and readjusting to everyday life complexities can pose substantial difficulties.

The Support Network Challenge: The absence of a reliable support network can exacerbate the difficulty of leaving religious orders. Individuals contemplating departure often find themselves isolated and lacking the guidance and resources necessary for a smooth transition. Building new social connections and seeking assistance from support groups or therapists becomes crucial in mitigating these challenges.

Emotional Manipulation and Gaslighting: Within certain religious orders, members may face emotional manipulation and gaslighting tactics that impede their decision-making process to leave. These harmful practices can induce doubt, guilt, and self-blame, making it exceedingly difficult for individuals to recognize their own agency and assert their desire to leave.

The Implications of Identity Shift: The leaving process inevitably triggers profound identity shifts for religious order members. Wresting control over one’s life choices and reestablishing a personal identity can be overwhelming. Filled with uncertainty, those transitioning away from religious orders often face an arduous journey to reconstruct their sense of self, incorporating newfound agency and personal beliefs.

Conclusion: The decision to leave a religious order is laden with a multitude of challenges, spanning psychological, emotional, societal, and spiritual realms. Understanding and empathizing with these difficulties is paramount in providing support and resources to facilitate the complex process of adjusting to life outside the religious institution. By recognizing the complex web of factors at play, society can foster an environment of acceptance and inclusivity for individuals who choose to navigate their own paths beyond religious orders.

Available November 24th, 2023

Title is now available for order from our shop

-Direct orders can take up to 3 weeks to deliver-


Book Details

6.000″ x 9.000″ (229mm x 152mm)
0.53830 in (13.67 mm)
Weight: 0.768 lb (348.36 g)
Black & White: White 50
Paperback: Perfect Bound

BISAC [FIC009000, DRA000000, NON000000] 
List Price: $18.00 [Print], $9.99 [Digital]

This content is available to premium users only. To enroll in the platinum plan, please visit Fan Box Plans.